2   | cups | Flour | All-purpose |
1   | tsp | Baking soda | |
1   | cup | Unsalted butter | 2 sticks, softened |
1   | cup | Sugar | |
1   | cup | Light brown sugar | Firmly packed |
4   | Large eggs | At room temperature | |
6   | oz | Unsweetened chocolate | |
1   | cup | Buttermilk | |
1   | tsp | vanilla extract |
6   | Butterfingers | King sized | |
    | bag | Mini Butterfingers | |
1   | stick | Unsalted butter | Softened |
1/2 | cup | Peanut butter | |
1   | cup | Powdered sugar | |
3-4   | Tbsp | Whole milk | As needed |
    | Food coloring | Orange gel I don't use it. *See Note 1 below. |